A frequently expressed comment in response to a recent motel molka scandal:
In the meantime, in the Sinophone world:
Advertisements
Déjà vu, déjà entendu [7]
Reply
Two sides of the same coin
‘Escape the corset’: South Korean women rebel against strict beauty standards (Benjamin Haas, The Guardian, 26 October 2018)
Lipstick, hair dye, & power — How beauty is fuelling a revolution in North Korea (Lexy Lebsack, Refinery29, 18 May 2019)
Challenge accepted [2]
I created a Twitter account in 2007, but have always been a half-hearted user. The reason has been quite simply the restriction on message length. However, in the age of TLDR, being able to summarise research findings in one or two tweets seems to be an increasingly useful skill. So, here we go, my attempts.
# […] The thesis was that the Internet is as much a ‘metaphor’ as a technology, and successful e-campaigns have been those tapping into the former discursively (rather than the latter logistically). (9 March 2019)
# […] News articles that attracted a large amount of reactions from readers and articles that drew *divisive* reactions were two distinct groups [in our new Quality & Quantity piece]. (23 April 2019)
Staying afloat
One of the questions I get most frequently from students upon their return from the field is “What now?”. They come back gloriously with tens of hours of interview recordings, pages after pages of ethnographic fieldnotes, and gigabytes of photos and news clippings, and they all say — understandably — that they feel overwhelmed by the challenge ahead of staying afloat and making headway in that sea of unstructured data.
RT @JessicaCalarco Doing qualitative research often feels like playing Jeopardy – you can see the answers (i.e., the patterns you find in your data), but you don’t always know the question (i.e., the problem those patterns solve). (21 December 2018)
I share with them well-established tips such as ease into it, embrace the messiness, keep an audit trail, put oneself in the reader’s [examiner’s] shoes, read what you want to write et cetera. These tips have all been highly appreciated, but then there are every now and then situations where students are still looking for something more concrete and readily usable in their research while I consciously try to be less prescriptive and more ‘Socratic’ (so to say). Those situations always feel to me like we are communicating back-scratching coordinates.
While I maintain that I shouldn’t be, and cannot be, too prescriptive, I thought I’d put together a nice ‘mixtape’ of resources for them. More will be added on.
For code-based theory building (as in GT)
- Life with and without coding: Two methods for early-stage data analysis in qualitative research aiming at causal explanations (Jochen Gläser & Grit Laudel, 2013, Forum: Qualitative Social Research 14(2), Art. 5)
- The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers (Johnny Saldara, 2015, 3rd ed.)
- “OK I’ve done all my coding. What’s next?” Err, didn’t you plan that already? (Christina Silver, Five Level QDA, 7 November 2017)
- Flexible coding of in-depth interviews: A twenty-first-century approach (Nicole M Deterding & Mary C Waters, 2018, Sociological Methods & Research)
- When coding doesn’t work, or doesn’t make sense: Synoptic units in qualitative data analysis (Nick Hopgood, 23 November 2018)
For ‘Big Qual’ analysis
- Big data, qualitative style: A breadth-and-depth method for working with large amounts of secondary qualitative data (Emma Davidson et al., 2018, Quality & Quantity; also as a podcast)
- Sample size in qualitative research (@drkakali, 2 December 2018)
- Analysing large volumes of complex qualitative data: Reflections from a group of international experts (Susie Weller et al., 2019, NCRM Working Papers)
- Big Qual Analysis Research Hub
For thematic analysis
- Using thematic analysis in psychology (Virginia Braun & Victoria Clarke, 2008, Qualitative Research in Psychology 3(2): 77-101)
- Qualitative data analysis: Exploring themes, metaphors and stories (Catherine Cassell & Vicky Bishop, 2018, European Management Review)
For framework analysis
- Qualitative data analysis for applied policy research (Jane Ritchie & Liz Spencer, 1994, in A. Bryman & R. G. Burgess, Analyzing Qualitative Data, pp.173-194)
- A practical iterative framework for qualitative data analysis (Prachi Srivastava & Nick Hopwood, 2019, International Journal of Qualitative Methods)
For discourse analysis
- Discourse and Social Psychology: Beyond Attidues and Behavioiur (Jonathan Potter & Margaret Wetherell, 1987)
- Discourse analysis video tutorial (Sarah Riley & Sally Wiggins, 2016)
- Not everything is a discourse (Dariusz Galasiński, 12 July 2017)
What we mean by a ‘case’ when we say we do case studies
- A case in case study methodology (Christine Benedichte Meyer, 2001, Field Methods 13(4): 329-352)
- Case study as a research strategy: Some ambiguities and opportunities (Piet Verschuren, 2003, International Journal of Social Research Methodology 6(2): 121-139)
- The curious case of case study: A viewpoint (Malcolm Tight, 2010, International Journal of Social Research Methodology 13(4): 329-339)
- What is a case, and what is a case study? (Hervé Dumez, 2015, BMS 127(1): 43-57)
Then and now
Just came back from a conference on “migration, mobility, and borders”, organised by and for our doctoral researchers. Interestingly, I was invited to give a ‘career talk’. My immediate suggestion was to bring in a career consultant instead, but for a combination of a couple of reasons, I ended up doing the talk. Come to think of it, I have been living and working among doctoral and early career researchers for almost 15 years, while being required to monitor the latest developments in the sector, so I told myself that I might indeed have one or two things to say about for their benefit.
Considering the theme, I prepared my talk along the lines of the increased expectation of (early career) researchers to be available/willing to be globally mobile. That is just one of the many, previously non-existent expectations imposed on the current generation of PhD candidates. I included this image (as a GIF) in my slides because every time I see it, I think of them. I honestly do.
Here are a couple more items that highlight how far things have changed in the PhD game.
# 2015 advice for your 856-year-old Ph.D. (Christian Sandvig, 5 August 2015)
# Academic superheroes? A critical analysis of academic job descriptions (Pitt & Mewburn, 2016)
# 100 years of the PhD (Bogle, 2017, Vitae)
# The UK doctorate: history, features and challenges (Deem & Dowle, 2018 [email of 12 January 2019)
# “How I Got My First Academic Job, 1965 ed” (@profmusgrave, 20 March 2019)
# Thesis declaration, now and then (source: Got this off Twitter two months ago, but despite my best efforts, I can’t trace back to the original link. Let me know!)
+ Speaking of thesis declarations, see also Stephen Hawking’s – one that broke the internet.
A gendered tale from South Korea
Global Digital Futures – E09. Molka and Online Violations of Women in South Korea
I was honoured to be invited to the SOAS Coding Club, a student-led radio station on campus, the first tech one at that, last week to talk about the ongoing molka epidemic in South Korea. When the host Chipo and I were discussing a possible podcast on my latest essay on the subject and picking a date for recording, obviously we didn’t know that our conversation would be aired amid newer and bigger scandals such as a K-pop idol and his involvement in running a club that has been alleged to be a ‘date rape hub’, another K-pop celebrity being caught for years’ worth of sharing of his sex videos (filmed without his partners’ knowledge) with fellow celebrities for male bonding, and the arrests of two men for secretly filming 1,600 hotel guests and streaming the footage live as pay-per-view porn.
There is so much to process here, but in the meantime, I have listened to the full 26 minutes of recording – despite the inevitable cringe that comes from listening to one’s own voice!!! – and realised two errors I made that I would like to iron out.
- I should have said passers-by, not passer-bys. (15:52)
- It was the Prime Minister’s Office that tweeted out those ridiculous anti-molka cartoons, not the Ministry of the Interior and Safety [let alone Internal Affairs]. (19:40)
Anthropology in the digital worlds [2]
Earlier this week I organised a lecture by a Professor of Anthropology on ethnographic methods for doctoral researchers across other disciplines. I stayed for the full session myself too. As I have said on this blog repeatedly already, my attitude towards anthropology is like that of a fangirl. I admit that must have a lot to do with my romanticised idea of the discipline. Nevertheless, my suspicions were confirmed when the professor said that anthropologists have a special relationship with ethnographic methods, feeling that they *own* the methods, even though the methods are now popularly used in many other disciplines too. (In fact on several occasions he used “anthropological methods” and “ethnographic methods” interchangeably.) And it broke my heart a little when he described anthropology as distinct from studies of texts, archives, and … the internet. It didn’t seem that anyone was bothered by that split-second remark, but to me it felt like someone closed the door on me – a door to a cool club that I was snooping around, hoping to be invited in.
Anyway, it was a fantastic talk and I was able to take away many gems of reading suggestions.
- Argonauts of the Western Pacific: An Account of Native Enterprise and Adventure in the Archipelagoes of Melanesian New Guinea (Bronislaw Malinowski, 1922) – especially the introduction.
- Writing Culture (James Clifford & George E. Marcus, 1986/2010).
- Enforcing Order (Didier Fassin, 2013).
- The Political Biography of an Earthquake: Aftermath and Amnesia in Gujarat, India (Edward Simpson, 2014).
- The Bachelors’ Ball: The Crisis of Peasant Society in Béarn (Pierre Bourdieu, 2007).
- The Weight of the World: Social Suffering in Contemporary Society (Pierre Bourdieu et al., 2000) – especially the interview sections.
- The history of Bhuj as told by its own historians (Edward Simpson & Kai Kresse, 2007).
- Fieldwork and the perception of everyday life (Timothy Jenkins, 1994).
- Keepers of the Flame: Understanding Amnesty International (Stephen Hopgood, 2006).
- The anthropology of international development (David Mosse, 2013).
Thesis Psychosis [4]
Saw a YouTube video of this song on a random blog many years ago. I liked it, but after that blog disappeared I couldn’t recall for the life of me the singer’s name. So, the video became one of those things that I don’t think about at all most of the time but when it springs to my mind out of the blue I will do some obsessive searching for in vain and leave until the next time it happens. Or to be more factual, one of my many digital objects of procrastination.
Then last week it just came back – equally out of the blue. Not the very same rendition but I take it.
Déjà vu, déjà entendu [6]
Lost in translation
Whelks caught in Wales are South Korean ‘aphrodisiac’ (Neil Prior, BBC News, 10 February 2019)
👆 You are witnessing how an ‘urban legend‘ is born. An ‘Othered’ one at that. Whelks are not considered as aphrodisiac in Korea. It is a horrendous slang word to refer to women who have passed out on date rape drugs.
